Homula Realty Brokerage
The information provided herein must only be used by consumers that have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale, or lease of real estate and may not be used for any commercial purpose or any other purpose.

537 Ste Marie Street, Collingwood, ON L9Y 3L2

5 beds · 2 baths · 2 kitchens · 9 rooms · 4 parking spaces · 1500-2000 sq ft · Laundry on the main level level · Detached
$699,000
Property tax
$2,935 / year

UNIQUE OPPORTUNITY to purchase a delightful 3 Bedroom Victorian heritage property with wrap around porch and ample parking in an excellent location and only a short walk to downtown Collingwood. Currently being rented as 2 separate units, front unit will be vacant with rear tenant open to staying on. Front unit consists of: Open Concept Kitchen/Dining area with tile floor, Family Room with wood floor & gas fireplace, 3 Bedrooms, oversized 4PC Bathroom. Rear unit consists of: Dining/Kitchen/Living Room, Primary Bedroom, Bedroom/Den and 4PC bathroom. Pretty sitting area on the porch to enjoy a morning coffee or afternoon tea and with use of the side garden. Large rear garden awaits your creation/design. Numerous & exciting future opportunities await the new owner with vision for a dream home of this well located Collingwood property. Walk to many local amenities, shopping, restaurants, theatre and library. Approx. 10 minute drive to Village at Blue Mountain. Hike/Cycle the trail and enjoy numerous festivals and events that take place in the area.

MLS number
S13127624
Type
Detached
Status
Active
Bedrooms
5
Bathrooms
2
Postal code
L9Y 3L2
Photos
46
Laundry
Main Level level
124days · this listing
Total days on market across every earlier listing of this propertyRegistration and sign-in required

This listing’s own days on market are shown above. How long the property has been for sale across every earlier listing is drawn from records the board releases only to registered users — a free account opens it, along with the sale history below.

Listing history

No previous listings found for this address.

Where this property is

Where this address sits, matched against open government data.

Estimated from the house-number range along this road: the right block of the right street, not the exact building. No address file publishes this house.

Schools

The school boundaries this address is inside, and the schools nearest it. Boards redraw boundaries and cap programs — confirm with the board before this affects a decision.

Other schools nearby

By distance from this address, not school boundary — a school 400 m away can be in another school’s attendance area.

SchoolLevelDistanceRating
Collingwood Collegiate Institute
Simcoe County DSB
Secondary542 m6.7 / 10
67% met the standard · 2 of 6 measures
Our Lady of the Bay Catholic High School
Simcoe Muskoka CDSB
Secondary567 m7.1 / 10
71% met the standard · 2 of 6 measures
Cameron Street Public School
Simcoe County DSB
Elementary648 m7.2 / 10
72% met the standard
ÉÉC Notre-Dame-de-la-Huronie
CS catholique MonAvenir
Elementary953 m7.1 / 10
71% met the standard
Little House Montessori SchoolElementary996 mNot reported
Connaught Public School
Simcoe County DSB
Elementary1.0 km6.1 / 10
61% met the standard
How the rating is calculated

EQAO — Ontario’s testing agency — publishes, for each school, the percentage of students meeting the provincial standard in Grade 3 and Grade 6 reading, writing and mathematics. The rating is the average of those percentages divided by ten. A school where 72% of students met the standard rates 7.2 out of 10.

Nothing is weighted or adjusted, and schools are not ranked against each other. Where EQAO withholds a result to protect the privacy of a small group of students, that measure is left out rather than counted as zero — so a rating built on fewer than six measures says so.

What it does not measure. It is one year of standardised testing in three subjects. It says nothing about teaching, programs, or whether a school suits a particular child, and it tracks neighbourhood household income closely enough that it partly measures the neighbourhood rather than the school. Treat it as one figure among many.

Source: Ontario Ministry of Education, School Information and Student Demographics (2024–25), Open Government Licence – Ontario.

H-Value

our estimate of this home is for registered usersWhat comparable homes nearby actually sold for, worked into an estimate for this one — with the range it sits in and how far the method has been off in testing.Create a free accountAlready have one? Sign in.

What an H-Value is and how it is calculated — the method and our measured error, no account needed.

The market around this home

Detached houses in Collingwood484 sales over the last five years.

Median sold priceWhat comparable homes actually sold for
$696k$782k$868k20252026this home’s asking price
$853klatest quarter · hover to read any
Sold vs askingAbove 100% means bidding wars were normal
95%98%100%20252026the asking price
96%latest quarter · hover to read any
Days to sellMedian days on market before the deal closed
-1d29d59d20252026
30dlatest quarter · hover to read any
How these are built, and what they cannot tell you

Each point is the median of the sales that closed in that quarter among detached houses in collingwood. A quarter with fewer than eight is left out rather than drawn, and the line breaks where that happens — a median over three sales is really one home’s price, and joining across a gap would draw a number nobody measured.

This is not an estimate of what this home is worth. The segment is a property type in an area; it takes no account of this home’s size, condition, renovations, lot, exposure or how it compares to its neighbours, and half the homes in any quarter sold for more than the median and half for less. It is context for a conversation with an agent, not a valuation.

Toronto Regional Real Estate Board closed transactions. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed accurate by PropTx.

This neighbourhood

Statistics Canada 2021 Census, for the surrounding few blocks — about 448 people.

$82,000Median household income
61%Own their home
69.2%Detached houses
50Median age
9.1%Born outside Canada
19.3%University degree

The neighbourhood, by the census

Statistics Canada 2021 Census for dissemination area 35430890 — the few blocks around this address, home to 448 people. It describes the area, not this property.

448Population
46.6Average age
2.2Household size
$98,000Average household income
$82,000Median household income
61%Own their home
39%Rent
0%Condominiums
9%Born outside Canada
19%University degree
$900,000Average home value
10%Low income
52%Not in the labour force
24%Never married
$20,000 to $24,9992%
$25,000 to $29,9992%
$30,000 to $34,9994%
$35,000 to $39,9996%
$40,000 to $44,9992%
$45,000 to $49,9992%
$50,000 to $59,9994%
$60,000 to $69,9996%
$70,000 to $79,9996%
$80,000 to $89,9996%
$90,000 to $99,9994%
$100,000 and over28%
$100,000 to $124,9996%
$125,000 to $149,9996%
$150,000 to $199,9996%
$200,000 and over10%

Percentages are of the 250 responses in this category. Statistics Canada rounds counts and withholds small ones to keep individuals unidentifiable, so categories with too few people to publish are absent rather than shown as zero.

Source: Statistics Canada, 2021 Census of Population. Contains information licensed under the Open Government Licence – Canada.

Work out the numbers

Everything below is calculated in your browser from figures you can change. Nothing is sent anywhere.

$139,800 · minimum here is $44,900
$3,095.02per month
Borrowed before insurance$559,200
Total borrowed$559,200
Interest over 25 years at 4.5%$369,306

If you rented it out

-$3,339.60per month out of pocket
Rent$0.00
Everything it costs to hold$3,339.60
How this is calculated, and what it leaves out

Canadian fixed-rate mortgages compound semi-annually, not monthly, so the monthly rate here is (1 + rate/2)1/6 − 1. Most calculators use rate ÷ 12, which is the American convention and overstates the payment by tens of dollars a month.

Below 20% down, default insurance is mandatory and is added to the loan rather than paid at closing: 2.80% at 85% loan-to-value, 3.10% at 90%, 4.00% at 95%. It is unavailable at or above $1.5M, which is why 20% is a hard floor there.

Not included: vacancy, property management, capital repairs, income tax, and the fact that a lender qualifies you at a stress-test rate rather than the one you are quoted. This is arithmetic on the numbers above, not a mortgage approval or an opinion of what you can afford.

Listed by Chestnut Park Real Estate. Listing data provided by the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board.